Off the Clock

Unemployed people have time on their hands, you say? Sure, if by “time” you mean the ability to travel backward through time.

I would have thought it was impossible, too, until esteemed economist Arthur Laffer set me straight with his recent op-ed in the Wall Street Journal. Laffer was arguing that it is economically counterproductive to raise unemployment benefits during economic hard times—say, now, for example—because it only creates disincentives for people to work:

Imagine what the unemployment rate would look like if unemployment benefits were universally $150,000 per year. My guess is we’d have a heck of a lot more unemployment. Common sense and personal experience indicate higher unemployment benefits will make unemployment less unattractive and thereby increase unemployment even in the Great Recession.

Can’t argue with that. True, unemployment benefits aren’t actually $150,000 a year—about three times the median household income in 2008. They’re closer to just $300 a week, or $15,600 a year. This hypothetical argument that supposes the exact opposite of reality, that one could on average make much more money by being unemployed, is nevertheless irrefutably compelling.

What really persuaded me, though, was this graph that Laffer and the WSJ supplied to bolster the argument that “since the 1970s there’s been a close correlation between increased unemployment benefits and an increase in the unemployment rate.”

The correlation is indeed close—with increases in unemployment benefits lagging spikes in unemployment by a year or so. This can only mean one thing. Those unemployed layabouts are using some of their $150,000 a year incomes to lounge around in Hot Tub Time Machines, jump back in time and get themselves laid off and so that they can soak up all that sweet, sweet government gravy.

Laffer is apparently not alone in his profession in believing that time travel is a major influence on the U.S. economy. Nobel laureate economist Edward C. Prescott recently stated at the Society for Economic Dynamics meeting in Montreal that Obama caused the current recession, which is a neat trick because the recession started in December 2007.

In summary, then, the keys to time travel are: (1) Lose your job. (2) Study economics.

4 thoughts on “Off the Clock

  1. Pingback: Twitted by aaronsw
  2. As a person who is presently unemployed I can offer some small anecdotal evidence in support of Laffer – in short, I’m not looking for another job because what I earn working odd jobs for cash added to what I’m getting in jobless benefits is more than what I can earn if I just go out and get another job like the one I had – that’s a pretty strong incentive to stay on benefits for as long as I possibly can – and I know for a fact what I’m doing is not that unusual, at least among people I know. Now, you may frown on this behavior, but to a ‘common working man’ of humble means [a state of affairs most scribblers in economics are no doubt far removed from] it all makes sense.


Comments are closed.